Do you cost more than you’re worth?
“No fat chicks.” That sign might as well hang over the port of entry in Auckland. Just ask Rowan Trezise, who was refused permission to enter the country with her husband when the New Zealand emigration board ruled she was not eligible for residency. Her failing? Having a BMI greater than 35.
Thinking the case could have been sensationalized in the press, I wanted to track down the details for myself. My line of inquiry led me to the Emigrate New Zealand and their discussion forum on “medicals,” the mandatory physicals taken by those who wish to live in New Zealand. Sure enough, BMI is enough to get a person blacklisted.
Why?
It’s all about the money.
From The Medical Examiner’s Handbook:
New Zealand has a publicly funded health system. Over recent years pressure on this system has grown, with the demand for services in some instances outweighing available funding and resources. Within this context, concern has also grown about the impact of migrants on the health and special education services that are in short supply. Migrants to New Zealand have always had to have an acceptable standard of health to be granted temporary entry to, or residence in, New Zealand.
Simply being obese disqualifies a person from receiving an acceptable standard of health certificate. Potential health problems associated with obesity could eventually cost the medical system money, so the answer is to bar fat people from entry, without consideration of fitness or health. It doesn’t matter whether the emigrant is there on a needed worker visa, or is a family member of someone who is. Weigh too much, forget it. The acceptable weight worker can enter, but only if s/he leaves the obese spouse or child behind.
It’s easy to excuse discrimination based on weight. But that reasoning so easily expands to cover other situations. For example, having a child in need of special education is enough to have that child’s entrance refused as well. I can think of a long list of conditions that are expensive to treat, including bipolar and many physical disabilities. I don’t believe my disorder invalidates the contribution I can make to society or an employer, above and beyond the cost of my treatment. The same is true of weight.
I wish New Zealand would recognize that.



